In 2025, Yelp has crowned the best seafood restaurants in New England, showcasing six regional eateries that have captured the hearts and palates of seafood enthusiasts across the region. From lobster bisque to paella and lobster rolls, these top picks promise a culinary journey that celebrates the bounty of the sea. With an increasing interest in seafood-based cuisine evident in rising internet searches, it’s clear that diners are eager to savor the flavors of the ocean.
Yelp’s Top Picks for Best Seafood Restaurants in New England
Among the standout winners are Turner’s Seafood in Salem, Massachusetts, Supreme Seafood Restaurant in North Branford, Connecticut, Paella Seafood in Portland, Maine, Hooked Seafood Restaurant in Manchester, New Hampshire, Matunuck Oyster Bar in South Kingstown, Rhode Island, and The Gryphon in Burlington, Vermont. Each establishment offers a unique culinary experience, showcasing the freshest seafood and innovative dishes that have earned them a spot on Yelp’s prestigious list.
At Turner’s Seafood in Massachusetts, diners rave about the “rich and creamy” lobster bisque, a dish so popular that it boasts its own fan club with over 300 glowing Yelp reviews. Meanwhile, Supreme Seafood Restaurant in Connecticut is known for its lobster rolls and fried-fish platters, described as “perfection on a plate” by satisfied customers. In Maine, Paella Seafood’s signature paella brims with prawns, mussels, calamari, and more, earning it the title of “seafood heaven” among patrons.
Explore the Seafood Scene in New England
New Hampshire’s Hooked Seafood Restaurant delights guests with its New England lobster roll, featuring “big meaty chunks” that showcase the restaurant’s commitment to quality and flavor. Over in Rhode Island, Matunuck Oyster Bar stands out for its fresh oysters, with diners praising the briny goodness that needs no additional sauce to shine. And at The Gryphon in Vermont, the Vineyard Chowder steals the show, packed with shrimp, scallops, clams, crab, haddock, and potatoes in a flavorful seafood broth that has diners calling it “beyond excellent.”
Yelp’s selection process for the best seafood restaurants in New England involved analyzing reviews that mentioned “seafood,” taking into account geographic location, review volume, and overall ratings to compile a list that showcases the region’s culinary gems. As seafood enthusiasts continue to seek out top-quality dining experiences, these restaurants have set the bar high for unforgettable seafood fare that celebrates the flavors of the sea.
What’s your favorite seafood restaurant in New England? Share your thoughts, culinary adventures, and seafood cravings with us by filling out the survey below or emailing us at [email protected]. Your seafood story could be featured in a future Boston.com article or on our social media channels, sparking a conversation that celebrates the vibrant seafood culture of New England.
Kristi Palma, a culture writer for Boston.com, immerses herself in New England travel, exploring the best airlines, hotels, and attractions that the region has to offer. From scenic vistas to culinary delights, she shares her insights and recommendations through her weekly travel newsletter, Scenic Six, guiding readers on a journey of discovery through New England’s diverse travel landscape. Sign up for Scenic Six and embark on an adventure that celebrates the beauty and charm of New England.
